Book a Call
ADA-minded accessibility
When “It Looks Fine” Isn't Enough
Accessibility lawsuits can feel abstract until you see how they play out for a real small business. And when they do, it is rarely about negligence. It is about not knowing what you do not know.
Case study
What a boutique retail lawsuit teaches every business with a website.
In 2019, a small online retailer, Midvale Corporation, became the center of a case that sent a clear message to small businesses everywhere.
Premade themes
Why premade themes still put your business at risk
One of the biggest misconceptions small businesses have is this: “If I use a reputable platform or theme, I am covered.”
You are not.
Platforms like Shopify, Wix, Squarespace, WordPress, and GoDaddy all offer professionally designed themes. They make it easy to launch a site quickly, and on the surface, everything looks polished and functional.
But themes are built for speed and design, not guaranteed accessibility compliance.
The hidden problems themes do not solve
- Missing or incorrect alt text on images
- Poor heading structure that screen readers cannot interpret
- Navigation that does not work with a keyboard
- Low color contrast that makes content unreadable
- Forms without proper labels or error messaging
To a business owner, the site still “looks fine.” To someone using assistive technology, it can be unusable.
Why this is where lawsuits start
Many of the businesses facing accessibility lawsuits did not build custom sites. They used templates. They followed the platform's guidance. They assumed the platform handled compliance.
That is exactly where things go wrong. Legally, it does not matter what platform you used. If your website is not accessible, your business is still responsible.
Real platform example
A Shopify store owner was sued without warning
In a widely cited story published by Shopify, a small online store owner described how an ADA website lawsuit arrived without a customer complaint or warning.
“Everything was going great... then I woke up to an email from an attorney.”
The business owner had used an ecommerce platform and was still pulled into legal action over alleged website accessibility barriers. That is the part small businesses cannot afford to miss: using a known platform does not transfer responsibility away from the business.
Automated scanning
How bots are identifying vulnerable websites
Many small business owners are caught off guard by accessibility lawsuits because they assume someone had to manually find and report their website.
That is not always the case.
Today, automated tools, often run at scale, can scan websites in seconds and flag common accessibility issues like missing alt text, poor color contrast, broken navigation, or improperly structured content.
These tools are widely used in web development, and they can also be used to analyze large numbers of websites quickly. That means it is entirely possible for sites to be identified at scale, especially when they share the same underlying problems.
When “it looks fine” isn't enough
Midvale Corporation operated the website for a boutique clothing brand, Avanti. From a visual standpoint, the site worked: clean design, functional shopping experience, nothing obviously broken.
But for a blind customer using screen reader software, the experience was completely different. She could not navigate the site properly. She could not understand product details. She could not complete a purchase.
So she sued.
What the court decided
The case went all the way to the California Court of Appeal, and the ruling was clear:
- The website was considered a place of public accommodation.
- It was not accessible to users with disabilities.
- That lack of accessibility violated California's Unruh Civil Rights Act.
Midvale did not just have to fix the site. The company was ordered to pay damages and legal fees.
The part that matters most for small businesses is this: it did not matter that the site looked good. It did not matter that the business did not intend to exclude anyone. What mattered was that someone could not use it.
Why it landed
This case hit small businesses hard.
This was not a massive corporation with endless resources. It was a relatively small retail operation, exactly the kind of business that assumes lawsuits like this happen to someone else.
Why smaller businesses can be exposed
Cases like this are often easier to bring against smaller companies:
- They are less likely to have legal defenses in place.
- Their websites are often built without accessibility in mind.
- They may not respond quickly, or correctly, to demand letters.
- They often rely on themes, apps, or plugins that change over time without a full accessibility review.
That combination makes them low-hanging fruit. A small business may have a beautiful storefront, loyal customers, and a strong product, but still have hidden barriers in product images, menus, popups, carts, or checkout.
The risk is not usually about bad intent. It is about technical details that were never checked closely enough before the site went public.
The pattern that keeps repeating
Stories like this follow a familiar path:
- A user encounters barriers on a website.
- A law firm identifies the issue.
- A demand letter is sent.
- The business scrambles under pressure while legal costs mount.
What actually went wrong
In cases like Thurston v. Midvale Corporation, the issues are rarely complex. They are foundational:
Missing alt text
Images need meaningful descriptions when they communicate important content.
Keyboard barriers
Navigation must work for people who do not use a mouse.
Poor structure
Screen readers depend on headings, landmarks, and clean hierarchy.
Unlabeled forms
People need to understand what each field asks for and how to complete it.
These are not edge cases. They are basics. But if accessibility is not part of the build process, they get missed every time.
The real cost is not just legal
Beyond the lawsuit, there is a deeper cost that can ripple through the whole business:
- Reputation damage: being publicly associated with discrimination claims, even when the issue came from an overlooked technical barrier.
- Lost customers: not just users with disabilities, but anyone who notices that the business feels difficult, outdated, or unsafe to use online.
- Operational stress: trying to fix everything quickly while legal bills, settlement pressure, and website rebuild costs are already mounting.
- Team impact: money that could have gone toward payroll, raises, inventory, marketing, or growth gets redirected into emergency response.
For small businesses, that kind of disruption hits hard because there is rarely a separate legal department, compliance team, or emergency budget waiting in the wings.
The takeaway
The lesson from this case is not fear. It is awareness.
Accessibility is not about perfection. It is about making sure your business is open to everyone and protected from preventable risk.
Because the businesses getting sued are not always the ones trying to do harm. They are often the ones who assumed their website was “good enough.”
Where Banba Creations comes in
Accessibility belongs in the foundation.
This is exactly why accessibility is built into every site at Banba Creations, from structure and speed to ADA compliance and SEO.
Not as an add-on. Not as a patch. As part of the foundation.
Because fixing a problem after a lawsuit is expensive. Building it right from the start is not.
Check your site for obvious accessibility issues
A free place to start is WAVE by WebAIM. Enter your website URL to flag many common accessibility and WCAG issues, then use the results as a starting point for deeper human review.
We checked this page in the tool and received a 10 out of 10 score. Check yours next.
Open the free WAVE checkerCopyright © 2026 Banba Creations LL Digital Media LLC. This article is provided for educational and informational purposes only and may not be copied, reproduced, republished, or distributed without prior written permission.
Build it right from the start
Ready for a website that is polished, strategic, and accessibility-minded?
Bring the site that needs a stronger foundation, the rebuild that has been waiting too long, or the launch that needs to be done properly from day one.